Act 2: A few hours later

The act opens with the Elkins alone in the store, contemplating what may happen to them at the end of the business day. Suddenly a group of children appear at the door singing a Christmas Carol. The Elkins invite them in to get warm and have a piece of candy. It is exciting for the children.
While the adults look on, Mr. Elkin takes time to teach the children that there is something much sweeter than candy. It's the love of God. "Don't forget about Jesus this Christmas," Mrs. Elkin warmly reminds them. "We would never forget him," one of the children replies. But the children know it is easy to forget about Him among the promises of pretty clothes, new toys and...well, candy! (Song: What Could Be Sweeter)

During the song, the children get an idea to stage a nativity for the Elkins. Using items they are wearing or found in the store, they all assume the various roles--Mary, Joseph, shepherd, sheep, wisemen and angels dancing before Jesus. It's a rag-tag little nativity, but it brings great pleasure to the Elkins in the midst of their day.

When they are about to leave Mr. & Mrs. Elkin decide to retrieve a leftover sandwich and some hot coffee from the back room. They also fill a box with candy. "Do you see that man out there," Mr. Elkin asked Joey, a young boy with a very sweet tooth. "He's cold and he's hungry. Take him this box of treats." Joey tries to keep the candy for himself. "Ain't ya gonna give him that sandwich and coffee. He doesn't need the candy too, does he?" Mr. Elkin put his arm around Joey and tells him he believes he'll do the right thing. "Will you be mad if I don't?" Joey asks. Mr. Elkin simply replies, "I believe God will help you do what is right." He sends Joey and his sister Jessica outside to Mr. Barnaby.

Barnaby is grateful for the warm beverage and the sandwich Jessica gives him. She turns to leave, waiting to see what her little brother will do. Reluctantly he presents the candy to the homeless man. In a surprise turn, Mr. Barnaby reaches in and takes a piece of candy out of the box. He knows the sacrifice young Joey is making. He hands the box back to the boy and thanks him for his kindness. "Share this with your sister," Mr. Barnaby encourages. The boy is thrilled and has gone away having learned a valuable lesson about kindness.